NPPF to address pension adequacy and governance concerns

TIL BDR GHALLEY | Thimphu

The Government has initiated a phased review of the National Pension and Provident Fund (NPPF), following concerns over the adequacy of retirement benefits, institutional governance and the long-term sustainability of the country’s pension system.

In its response to the recommendations made in the review of the NPPF, the Ministry of Finance and NPPF have outlined a series of proposed reforms, including reviewing pension contributions and benefits, strengthening institutional governance, separating pension and provident fund management and considering a dedicated law governing the fund.

The recommendations also raised concerns about early retirement, the retirement benefits of government contract employees, financial support for retired monks and nuns, and adjustments to pension payments in response to inflation and rising living costs.

On pension adequacy, the review highlighted the possibility of pensioners falling into old-age poverty because of insufficient retirement income. It recommended examining different parameters, including the replacement rate, pensionable service and employee contributions to the Provident Fund.

In response, the stakeholders acknowledged the concerns and said a phased, long-term reform was already underway following consultations among relevant stakeholders.

The ongoing review is supported by actuarial valuation, with proposed changes to be assessed for adequacy and long-term financial sustainability.

The Government said retirement-income adequacy would not be measured solely by the monthly pension payment. Instead, the assessment would consider the combined value of the Tier-I pension annuity, lump-sum Provident Fund benefits and gratuity.

The review also recognises the relationship between wage growth and retirement benefits, as both pension contributions and benefits are largely determined by an employee’s basic salary. According to the response, constraints on wage growth have affected the accumulation of contributions and the resulting pension benefits.

The stakeholders said the reform would consider these interconnected factors while balancing retirement-income adequacy, financial sustainability and intergenerational equity.

The review also recommended enacting a dedicated Pension and Provident Fund Act to establish the NPPF as an independent legal entity and strengthen its governance, accountability, operational independence and regulatory oversight.

The recommendation comes amid concerns about the institutional constraints faced by the NPPF under its existing arrangement.

The stakeholders supported the eventual enactment of either an Old Age Retirement Income Act or a Pension and Provident Fund Act. However, the final title and scope of the legislation would be determined based on the outcome of the reform process.

The Government has proposed a three-phase approach.

The first phase, which is already underway, focuses on reviewing pension parameters through actuarial studies. This includes the replacement rate, pensionable service, contribution rates and benefit structures. Proposed measures would be introduced progressively and, where appropriate, piloted to assess their affordability and sustainability.

The second phase will examine the NPPF’s institutional, governance and operational structure. This includes the management of pension and provident fund schemes and liabilities, institutional independence, the responsibilities of the Board and accountability arrangements.

The third phase will consider legislative and regulatory reforms after the first two phases have been sufficiently developed and tested.

The proposed legislation is expected to establish the institutional mandate, governance structure, fiduciary responsibilities, member protection provisions and regulatory and supervisory framework. The appropriate roles of the Royal Monetary Authority and other relevant institutions will also be determined in consultation with stakeholders.

The response noted that the existing Executive Order has enabled continuity in administering pension and provident fund benefits, unified management of the schemes and operational flexibility.

However, it acknowledged that an Executive Order might not provide the same statutory clarity and permanence as a dedicated law, particularly concerning institutional responsibilities, member protection and regulatory oversight.

Another recommendation called for the NPPF Board to be empowered in accordance with its founding Executive Order to strengthen governance autonomy and operational efficiency.

In response, the Ministry of Finance and NPPF maintained that the Board already has full decision-making authority under the Executive Order.

The response stated that the NPPF’s institutional position differs from that of conventional state-owned enterprises because its founding Executive Order reflects the intended autonomy of the Board.

The review also recommended including representatives from the Royal Civil Service Commission (RCSC) and the Ministry of Industry, Commerce and Employment (MoICE) on the National Pension Board.

The recommendation cited the significant proportion of civil servants among NPPF members, estimated at almost three-quarters of the total membership, and the need to expand coverage in the private sector.

The stakeholders acknowledged the need for broader representation but said the Board already includes three civil service representatives, alongside representatives from His Majesty’s Secretariat, the Cabinet Secretariat, the Royal Bhutan Army, the Ministry of Finance and an independent Board member.

The response said the Board should be strengthened primarily through professional expertise and competency rather than by adding more ex-officio members.

It maintained that separate representation from the RCSC and MoICE was not necessary at this stage, noting that civil service perspectives were already represented by serving civil servants on the Board.

For private-sector coverage, the stakeholders proposed structured policy coordination, technical working arrangements, stakeholder consultations and joint outreach between NPPF and MoICE instead of permanent representation on the Board.

The response also stated that Board members were expected to act in the interests of the NPPF and its entire membership rather than solely represent their respective institutions. However, the Board’s composition could be reviewed as part of the proposed structural and legislative reforms.

The review further highlighted the different nature of liabilities under the pension and Provident Fund schemes and recommended separating their fund and scheme management in line with international practices.

The Ministry of Finance and NPPF supported the recommendation in principle, stating that accounting-level separation of pension and provident fund liabilities was already in place.

However, the response said greater differentiation in their management and governance should be pursued progressively.

It noted that Bhutan’s domestic capital market was still developing and lacked the scale, depth and maturity required to support full separation of fund management without potentially affecting efficiencies in centralised asset unitisation, investment operations and liquidity management.

The stakeholders said the timing of such separation should depend on market readiness, institutional capacity and the development of the supporting financial ecosystem rather than a predetermined timeframe.

The review also raised concerns that, despite the extension of the pension vesting period from 20 to 23 years, a significant number of NPPF members continued to opt for early retirement to secure lump-sum benefits.

It recommended allowing employees who reach pensionable age to choose between receiving their Tier-I pension benefits or all retirement benefits as a lump sum.

The stakeholders acknowledged the concern and the preference among some members for greater access to lump-sum retirement benefits. However, they said a cautious approach was necessary.

The response referred to Bhutan’s experience under the earlier Gratuity and Government Employees’ Provident Fund schemes, where lump-sum retirement benefits were often exhausted within four to five years.

This, according to the response, left some retirees financially vulnerable and dependent on family support.

The stakeholders said the implications of allowing members to withdraw their Tier-I or entire retirement benefits as a lump sum needed to be carefully assessed against the objective of providing income security throughout retirement.

The review also highlighted the financial vulnerability of retired monks and nuns under the Zhung Dratshang welfare scheme, which is currently financed entirely through donations.

It recommended Government financial support to help elderly retired monks and nuns meet their basic needs and ensure the long-term sustainability of the scheme.

The stakeholders acknowledged the recommendation and said sustainable funding options needed to be examined because the scheme’s welfare and funding arrangements fell within the broader framework of budgetary policy.

NPPF has stated that it is prepared to provide fund administration, record-keeping and actuarial management services if the Government decides to extend budgetary or mandatory contribution support to the scheme.

The review also pointed to limited public understanding of NPPF schemes and retirement benefits, recommending stronger financial literacy and awareness programmes.

NPPF accepted the recommendation and said nationwide awareness initiatives were already underway.

These include digital self-service portals, pension benefit calculators and regional workshops for civil servants, corporate employees and private-sector members.

The fund is also expanding its outreach through social and mainstream media, while radio and television are being considered as additional channels to reach people who may not have access to digital platforms.

Another recommendation called for extending the Government’s matching Provident Fund contributions to government contract employees, in line with the benefits provided to regular employees.

The stakeholders acknowledged the recommendation and said NPPF was technically and operationally prepared to enrol all government contract personnel once the necessary budgetary approval was received.

However, implementation is linked to the forthcoming amendment to the Labour and Employment Act and the Pay Revision process, as the existing labour framework does not extend to this category of employment.

The response clarified that employees under contractual arrangements, including ESP, GSP and para-regular positions, receive Provident Fund benefits under the Civil Service Rules and relevant regulations.

Employees engaged under time-bound or ad hoc contracts are not covered by the pension scheme, consistent with the terms and nature of their employment.

It also noted that contractual remuneration packages are structured separately from those applicable to civil servants at equivalent position levels.

The final recommendation called for fair and reasonable adjustments to pension benefits to protect retirees from inflation and rising living costs.

Citing Articles 7(1) and 7(15) of the Constitution, the recommendation proposed that pension benefits should be considered for corresponding adjustments whenever serving public servants receive salary revisions.

The stakeholders acknowledged the importance of protecting pensioners’ purchasing power and stated that the existing system already provides for indexation of up to five percent.

However, they explained that the NPPF is a contributory occupational pension scheme in which benefits are determined by individual contributions. Consequently, pension payments are not automatically adjusted in line with salary revisions for serving public servants.

The response further stated that any increase in indexation beyond the existing mechanism, including adjustments linked to future salary revisions, would create significant unfunded actuarial liabilities unless supported by a dedicated capital injection.

The proposed reforms will therefore be considered through the broader review of the pension system, with actuarial assessments and institutional reforms informing decisions on the future structure and sustainability of the NPPF.

However, the National Council has recommended the need to have a dedicated Pension and Provident Fund Act to address these issues during the ongoing session of the National Council.

Related Posts

About The Author

Add Comment